Lieutenant 1
- 2022 Clayton West
- 2021 Ty Webb
- 2020 Tyler Bare
- 2019 Brian Robertson
- 2016 Nicholas McLaughlin
- 2015 Nicholas McLaughlin
- 2013 Robert Kauffman Jr.
- 2012 Cody Lockwood
- 2011 Greg Hocker
- 2010 Rancel Evans Jr.
- 2009 Rancel Evans Jr.
- 2008 Richie Walls
- 2007 Guy Rickards
- 2006 Robert Kauffman Jr.
- 2005 Norman Amendt
- 2004 Robert Cykosky
- 2002 Shawn Evans
- 2001 Eric Huovinen Sr.
- 1998 Norman Amendt
- 1997 Douglas Scott
- 1996 Douglas Scott
- 1994 Norman Amendt
- 1993 Norman Amendt
- 1992 Norman Amendt
- 1991 Richard L Thomas
- 1990 Richard L Thomas
- 1989 Norman Amendt
- 1988 Norman Amendt
- 1987 Norman Amendt
- 1986 Norman Amendt
- 1985 John Melson
- 1984 John Melson
- 1983 John Melson
- 1981 John Melson
- 1980 John Melson
- 1979 John Melson
- 1971 Rancel Evans Sr.
- 1970 Rancel Evans Sr.
