Lieutenant 2
- 2022 Michael Voeltner
- 2021 Clayton West
- 2020 Clayton West
- 2019 John Evans
- 2018 Greg Hocker
- 2017 Greg Hocker
- 2017 Tyler Bare
- 2014 Ty Webb
- 2012 Greg Hocker
- 2011 Taylor Bare
- 2010 Gregory Tietmeyer
- 2009 Greg Hocker
- 2008 Douglas Scott
- 2007 Gregory Tietmeyer
- 2006 Brian Mushrush
- 2005 Rancel Evans Jr.
- 2004 Robert Kauffman Jr.
- 2003 Eddie Hammond
- 2000 Bobby Magee
- 1999 Bobby Magee